Aïcha Snoussi, Le livre des anomalies (The book of anomalies) (2017)
Aïcha Snoussi’s Le livre des anomalies (The book of anomalies) is an installation work composed of ink drawings in school notebooks. The book of anomalies is a new taxonomy of items that confronts typical categorical organization and accepted definitions. Because the entries are unfamiliar, and their relationship to one another remains open, they elude hierarchy and expose the social construction inherent in meaning making and ranking systems. The figures within the notebooks are not unlike the exquisite corpses of the European Surrealists in which multiple people contributed sections of a drawing to create an assemblage. Patricia Allmer notes that “the (ideological) status quo is challenged in surrealism, by seeking and teasing out the marvelous in the everyday – without departing from it, surrealist strategies reveal the everyday and familiar as marvelously unknown, different from itself, differing from what ideologies dictate it to be.” Snoussi’s drawings reference known shapes – animals, plants, and bodies – yet they are strangely rendered and configured in unexpected, and uncanny, combinations.
In this work, Snoussi presents vaginal imagery alongside drawings with phallic components. As Elizabeth Grosz contends, the history of philosophy has refused to recognize the “formative role [of the body] in the production of philosophical values – truth, knowledge, justice, etc. [and] above all… the role of the specific male body as the body productive of a certain kind of knowledge (objective, verifiable, casual, quantifiable) has never been theorized.” Snoussi’s prioritization of human female genitalia and of deviant sexuality in a nonsensical reference book centers the female body and queer sexuality as sites of knowledge production. Here, Snoussi’s genital forms become part of a new knowledge system, one that is inherently queer and that draws from, yet ultimately rejects, the male and science centered ways of knowing that dominate modern thought.
The title of the work indicates that the figures in the books are anomalies: of bodies, genitals, and sexual acts and relationships. As Eve Sedgwick contends, “That’s one of the things that ‘queer’ can refer to: the open mesh of possibilities, gaps, overlaps, dissonances and resonances, lapses and excesses of meaning when the constituent elements of anyone’s gender, of anyone’s sexuality aren’t made (or can’t be made) to signify monolithically.”
Snoussi’s forms interrogate such monolithic significations, and with the word ‘anomalies,’ Snoussi evokes deviance and rejects the fetishization of the normal.
Anomalies are outliers, as are deviants. Sexual deviants, such as lesbians, gays, and bisexuals are those with sexual identities that exist in the margins of sexual hierarchy. Love summarizes the contemporary application of deviance, stating, “Queer critics [have] embraced deviance not as an inevitable counterpart to conforming behavior and an integral aspect of the social world, but rather as a challenge to the stability and coherence of that world.” The utility of embodied deviance and deviance in sexual practices and acts can therefore be as methods of destabilization to normalcy rather than states that can be assimilated.
In one pair of drawings, a polygonal shape appears like a vulva, opposite a bug-like creature with machine parts. On the vulval-shape, small lines, like hairs or folds, cover the outside areas and a small, bright point appears near the convergence of the two sides of the figure. By evoking human female genitalia, Snoussi’s imagery operates within, but in contrast to, power systems that determine hegemonic meanings. Human female genitals, coopted by patriarchal power structures, are made to symbolize a range of attributes related to the constructs of female, woman, femininity, gender, sex, sexuality, and so forth. Pierre Bourdieu discusses the gendered dimensions of genitalia, stating, “the social definition of the sex organs, far from being a simple recording of natural properties, directly offered to perception, is the product of a construction implying a series of oriented choices, or, more precisely, based on the accentuation of certain differences and the scotomization of certain similarities.”
The terms of female genitalia are set forth by a social agreement regarding first their purpose, procreation and pleasure for men, second their status as low, dirty, penetrable, vulnerable, and finally their aesthetics – beauty conditional upon cultural context and specific temporality, which increasingly in global beauty culture includes white, shaven, not menstruating, pre-pubescent appearing, labia minora laying neatly inside of labia majora, and clitoris not protruding from clitoral hood. Because a clearly sexed body is typically extrapolated to a clearly defined, singular gender, sexed bodies participate in producing the body as an entity without plurality. Snoussi’s uncanny genital shapes disturb such singularities.
The vulval figure is uncanny in several ways: it is disarticulated from a body, mediating its significance to the gendered body. A vulva that is uncoupled from the female body becomes at once both strange and familiar. As Whitney Chadwick contends, “In many cases Surrealism has provided the starting point for works that challenge existing representations of the female body as provisional and mutable, or at least initiating a shift away from the phallic organization of subjectivity.” Such surrealist, uncanny bodily arrangements as Snoussi’s vulval shapes work outside of normalcy. These forms often cut across the normative human or the body. Like Sedgwick, who delineates that the origins of the word queer (the Indo-European “twerkw” (across) and the German “quer” (transverse)) enable the term to cut across reductive conceptualizations of homosexuality, queer bodies might act at a “cross” angle to normative bodies. As J. Jack Halberstam and Ira Livingston contend, the “‘human body’ [is] a figure through which culture is oriented and processed.” Bodies and sexual parts that deny the ascription of sex and gender disturb such processes of orientation.
In the same detail image, a cord emerges from the vulvic area of the drawing. With a colorless segment near one end, the cord seems almost worm-like, while at the other end, something akin to a stinger seems to terminate the physical boundary of the object. Neither the worminess of the cord nor the presence of the stinger is accidental. Snoussi’s animal references illuminate, following Mel Y. Chen, the trans possibilities of animal genitalia. In particular, the worm’s clitellum, or smooth segment, a sexual organ that both provides and accepts sperm during intercourse, demonstrates the boundary-crossing potential of transgender, genderqueer, intersex, agender, or gender non-conforming as physical states. These conceptualizations are particularly disruptive to a Tunisian social order that prioritizes sex and gender fixity in the maintenance of the family, the society, and the state.
The mechanical-creature drawing paired with the genital-like representation is even more disorienting than its counterpart. It has very few, if any, apparent visual references that could serve to guide the viewer in identifying its components. In fact, some elements seem to reference parts of the vulval shape it faces, such as long, straight protrusions that echo the rectangles made up of parallel lines on its companion, or the folds that comprise some bodily weight in each. The merger of animal and machine enables the figure to be thought as a chimera.
There exists a potential for bodily plurality in many humans that is denied. As Chen points out “the ‘genitals’ are directly tied to social orders that are vastly more complex than systems of gender alone… Genitalia are culturally overdetermined, and, as the seats of reproduction and fecundity, they are sites of biopolitical interest not only for humans but for nonhuman animals.” Thus, in the violent gendering process, externally observable genital characteristics are in actuality being described as most like “male” or most like “female” and gender identity is “naturally” aligned with this physicality. For intersex and transgender individuals this is particularly relevant, as the illegitimacy of sex/gender systems are most apparent to people who exist outside of such organization.
As in many cultures, the sex assignment of Tunisian children based on genitalia is crucial to their existence as social subjects. The girl’s hymen is emphasized as the locus of social worth, while a boy child’s social acceptance is achieved through the highly ritualized circumcision ceremony, a celebration that can last several days. The circumcision ritual often marks the entry into male socialization. It is thus a method of gendering. The ceremony is sometimes even presented as a mock-wedding in which the boy wears bridegroom’s clothes and songs are sung about coitus. The girl’s hymen and the boy’s circumcision are components of the construction of the children as integral, gendered family members who will fulfill gendered roles within the family structure. The book of anomalies challenges hierarchies that result from meanings made within these social systems by divorcing genitals from gender and by alluding to deviant sexual relationships that derail heteropatriarchy.
In the nuclear family, gendered one-to-one relationships such as mother-daughter, manwoman, and brother-sister are prioritized. David Getsy asserts that,
Queer people are the only minority whose culture is not transmitted within the family. Indeed, the assertion of one’s queer identity often is made as a form of contradiction to familial identity. Thus, for queer people, all of the words that serve as touchstones for cultural identification – family, home, people, neighbourhood, heritage – must be recognized as constructions for and by the individual members of that community.
The importance of the heteronormative, monogamous family also aligns with sexuality. Gayle Rubin describes “a hierarchical system of sexual value” in which “marital, reproductive heterosexuals are alone at the top of the erotic pyramid. Clamoring below are unmarried monogamous heterosexuals in couples, followed by most other heterosexuals… Stable, longterm lesbian and gay male couples are verging on respectability.” Tunisian understandings of sexual hierarchy align with Rubin’s summary of modern Western societies in which the monogamous heterosexual couple is the pinnacle of sexual respectability, and differ in that premarital sex for women and homosexual sex, particularly for men, fall far below the measure of respectability. Pre-marital and homosexual sex acts performed by individuals also have ramifications for the family’s social status in Tunisia that are not always found in hegemonic Western understandings of sex.
Marriage remains critical to the social discipline of Tunisian women. Women’s rights in Tunisia may benefit women in many ways, and certainly many Tunisian woman enjoy liberties not granted to their counterparts in neighboring North African and Middle Eastern countries. However, many rights for Tunisian women given through the CPS are related to marriage and family. This structure codifies women’s rights on the conditions of marriage and within the context of heterosexual relationships. Women who are not married by age thirty, or women who are divorced, are stigmatized. Divorced women face economic repercussions as well as social ones.
As Charrad summarizes,
In a social system in which the law facilitates divorce, and where most women have no independent source of support, reliance on one’s kin group represents the main and most stable basis for security. Typically, divorced women go back to their father’s house, or… to the household of a male relative…The woman is also tied to her husband’s lineage, however, if only by the fact that her children belong to it. She is thus in an ambiguous status.
An unmarried or divorced woman is therefore a body that should be recuperated by the state for use in sexual and economic regeneration. While the state lays out the terms of women’s social existence through relationships to men and family – through marriage and children – it is society that upholds and enforces the state’s requirements. An unmarried or divorced Tunisian woman is subject to social stigma and is a cause for her family to be concerned. The unmarried or divorced woman has failed to reproduce the state in the correct manner: through the maintenance of the heterosexual, nuclear family unit. The book of anomalies problematizes heterosexual, nuclear family structure and the reproduction of such by highlighting female genitalia as active and focal, and by referencing deviant sex acts and desires.
The figures that reference genitals in The book of anomalies expose the social construction of genital biology because they demonstrate that human genitals are where human sexual difference manifests. As Pierre Bourdieu describes, “The body has its front, the site of sexual difference…It has its public parts – face, forehead, eyes moustache, mouth – noble organs of self-presentation which concentrate social identity…and its hidden or shameful private parts, which honour requires a man to conceal.” Bourdieu illuminates how genitals come to define sexual difference, as well as how sexual difference based on genitals is projected onto the “public” parts of a human. Judith Butler likewise contends that “sexual difference… is never simply a function of material differences which are not in some way both marked and formed by discursive practices.” Discursive practices help to materialize the categories of male and female, animal and human, and further divisions within each. Sexual difference is not unique to humans, as animal genitalia are also used to construct differently sexed creatures, and can also induce shame in their viewing. Yet, human genitalia are so imbued with such meanings of shame that they must be covered. An artwork such as The book of anomalies that denies genital ascription disrupts the biological fixity of sexual difference and its bodily materials by defamiliarizing categories of human, animal, and genital.
Anne Marie E. Butler.
In Unintelligible Bodies: Surrealism and Queerness in Contemporary Tunisian Women’s Art. State University of New York at Buffalo, ProQuest Dissertations Publishing, 2019.
Organicore CBD Gummies Benefits
I was recommended this website by my cousin I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble You are amazing Thanks
temp mail
It’s as if you read my mind. You seem to know a great deal about this, as if you wrote the book in it or something. Although I believe some images would help to drive home the point a bit more, other than that, this is an outstanding site. I will definitely return.
temp mail
I enjoy your website, obviously, but you should check the spelling on a number of your posts. A number of them have numerous spelling errors, which makes it difficult for me to tell the truth, but I will definitely return.
Utnvcoams
online pharmacy viagra usa
Kthnuade
can you take furosemide on an empty stomach
Xthfutith
lisinopril for diabetes
Syhkclisy
zoloft and weed
Ctntulse
is flagyl used for uti
Ktbnuade
lasix 20mg
Xjeutith
gabapentin 100 mg
Sheclisy
glucophage resistance
Xjjeutith
cephalexin 500mg capsule uses
Smgclisy
can i drink alcohol with amoxicillin
Kethnuade
gabapentin drug test
Cnnttulse
escitalopram 10 mg efectos secundarios
Snduclisy
can i give my cat human ciprofloxacin
Xmtfutith
cephalexin 500mg dosage for tooth infection
Kmehnuade
bactrim ds and alcohol
Xtnvutith
what are the side effects of cephalexin
Crmmtulse
bactrim ds dosage for tooth infection
Srngclisy
how does amoxicillin work
Ktncxnuade
max dose of gabapentin
Crndtulse
escitalopram 10 mg
Kmevnuade
can you drink with citalopram
Xnrutith
how long does depakote take to work
Srthvclisy
cozaar generic availability
Sergio686
Dating is a truly joyful experience. Sometimes we lose sight of this truth in our search for the right Online dating site
Crhctulse
ddavp for renal biopsy
Kmevnuade
stopping citalopram after 1 week
Xnrutith
how does depakote make you feel
Srthvclisy
cozaar patent date
Crhctulse
ddavp desmopressin side effects
twitch adblock
twitchadblocker twitch werbung blocken twitch adblock chrome Möchten Sie Live-Streaming genießen? twitch 広告ブロック, Aber es gibt Werbung, die Ihr Erlebnis ruiniert, dann laden Sie sie einfach herunter twitch adblock und genießen Sie das Streaming ohne Störung.
twitch ad block
Xthdutith
maximum dose of diclofenac
Kxebnuade
ezetimibe atorvastatin merck
Stehclisy
augmentin 875-125 mg
Cjeftulse
stopping diltiazem cold turkey
Xtmfutith
flexeril dose
Kxfcnuade
effexor xr side effects first week
Sedcclisy
flomax side effects anxiety
Kmtfnuade
allopurinol dosage during gout attack
Xtenutith
aripiprazole 15 mg side effects
Srncclisy
amitriptyline price
Ctmvtulse
aspirin formula
Kmrcnuade
celebrex dosage
Xssmnutith
baclofen controlled substance
Srmvclisy
can you cut bupropion in half
Csxxtulse
augmentin 875 mg
Kmhhnuade
celecoxib black box warning
Xncutith
ashwagandha reddit
Sxxeclisy
withdrawal effects of buspirone
Czzqtulse
celexa for panic attacks
Teleparty Extension
With the teleparty extension, you can watch Netflix, Youtube, Hulu, HBO and more simultaneously with friends. It’s perfect for movie nights with long-distance pals, featuring synced video playback, group chat, and audio/video calls to streaming sites.
netflix watch party
The netflix watch party is a browser extension that allows friends and family to watch Netflix together even when they are physically apart. While streaming, netflix watch together , netflix watch party extension , netflix viewing party, does netflix have watch party, watch party on netflix, netflixparty you can share your reactions with its incredible features like group chat and audio\video calls.
Krccnuade
actos english
Xtvcutith
how safe is semaglutide
Srcbclisy
does abilify cause hair loss
Cjuutulse
acarbose torrinomedica
Kxeenuade
remeron withdrawl
Xmhutith
robaxin dosage for humans
Sasfclisy
repaglinide therapeutic category
Czzutulse
protonix davis
legit non prescription pharmacies
canada pharmacy not requiring prescription
zestoretic 20 25 mg
buy zestril 20 mg online
Kxeenuade
remeron 30 mg
Zefbnuade
synthroid backorder
Bthjutith
spironolactone headache
Awsxclisy
sitagliptin 50 mg price
Makayla
Wow, superb weblog structure! How long have you ever been running a blog for?
you made running a blog glance easy. The entire look of your web site is great,
as smartly as the content! You can see similar here ecommerce
canadian pharmacy online cialis
northwest pharmacy canada
Zefbnuade
synthroid aggression
Zolknuade
tamsulosin usos
Bbbfutith
venlafaxine effexor
Ayybclisy
voltaren gel 1% walmart
Cnnytulse
what is tizanidine used to treat
Bryon
batmanapollo.ru
Zoljnuade
zyprexa drug class
Bmooutith
how much weight can you lose taking wellbutrin
Ammhclisy
zetia generic release date
cheap valtrex
valtrex 1000 mg daily
Cndytulse
zofran available in canada
tadalafil price from india
where can i get cialis over the counter
Zoljnuade
zyprexa iv
buy tadalafil 20mg
cheap canada cialis
bwerpipes agtech
Bwer Pipes – Your Trusted Partner for Agricultural Irrigation in Iraq: Explore Bwer Pipes for reliable irrigation solutions tailored for Iraqi agriculture. From durable pipes to advanced sprinkler systems, we have everything you need to optimize your crop yields. Visit Bwer Pipes
Cndytulse
zofran and pregnancy nausea
best australian online pharmacy
canadian happy family store coupon
HarryBiawn
you’re really a good webmaster. The web site loading velocity is amazing. It seems that you are doing any distinctive trick. In addition, The contents are masterpiece. you have done a wonderful job on this topic!
https://englishmax.ru/
zoritoler imol
You have noted very interesting details! ps nice site.
Zccrnuade
cialis pill canada
Bcedutith
vardenafil (levitra)
Axerclisy
levitra buy line
Ccxytulse
cheap brand cialis 20 mg